Thorin Goes On A Quest, and there’s a Hobbit involved in it too

I recently wrote a whole fanfic that revolved around Thorin Oakenshield, viewing the story in The Hobbit from his perspective. In the story, I pretended that Tauriel the elf was the catalyst for his growth–the one who brought him to the point of saying, at the very end, that if more people valued food and cheer over hoarded gold, the world would be a merrier place.

In my story, Thorin is barely listening to Bilbo as the hobbit makes his final speech. As I re-read that passage, I felt kind of bad, but then I told myself, Oh, come on, this is Thorin’s deathbed! He’s probably got a whole lot of things on his mind. Mostly (in my mind) he’s thinking about Tauriel.

But it just made me see that The Hobbit ought to focus on, well, the hobbit. That deathbed scene should be a big reconciliation between Thorin and Bilbo, a moment where their prickly bromance comes to a sweet resolution. As much fun as it was to write, my story shoved Bilbo out of his rightful place as the one responsible for Thorin’s transformation into an heroic character who dies a noble death.

Now I hope that this relationship between Thorin and Bilbo will be a central element of the film version of The Hobbit. No doubt it will be–I’m sure the filmmakers have been thinking about this stuff longer than I have. But we’ve been hearing a lot about Gandalf, and Thorin, and the dwarves generally, and it would be nice to hear more about Bilbo.
It is a tricky thing, though. Bilbo is modest, self-effacing and possesses no obvious heroic traits. He’s little, he’s fussy, and he’s kind of silly. He doesn’t even want to go on a big quest. Hmmm…

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Thorin Goes On A Quest, and there’s a Hobbit involved in it too

  1. As far as Thorin not paying much attention to Bilbo, I think that was the problem Bilbo had throughout the story. All the impressive feats he achieved were forgotten by the group two minutes after! It’s a long haul before he gets any lasting, deep-felt respect.

    I’m guessing Bilbo will be the practical one of the group, and audiences will relate to him because he’ll appear to be one of the only sane ones. The audience should feel empathy over his trouble fitting into the overwhelming company of dwarves.

  2. I bet Martin Freeman will find similarities between Bilbo and Dr. Watson (and Arthur Dent) in that regard–someone who’s flashier is getting all the attention!
    Looking forward to the Tolkien Professor’s podcasts on Bilbo. I listened to some of the other ones last night, which is what got me on this train of thought.

  3. Sometimes I get the feeling that Martin Freeman and Richard won’t have to stretch their acting muscles too far in this movie. It’s almost like they’ve been cast in the type of roles they have already proven to be highly effective at. There is nothing at all wrong with this. Save the 180 degree challenges for after this film!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s